The Statue of Liberty: An Evolving History

The history of the Statue of Liberty is the story of 3 countries—France, the United States, and Italy— the turbulent times in these countries in the mid to late 1800s, and the bonds these countries shared then and now.  As most Americans know, Liberty Enlightening the World was a gift from the French people in honor of the centennial of American independence.  Dedicated in 1886, it proudly stands 305 feet tall (to the top of the torch) overlooking the bay in Manhattan.

The statue was conceived in the 1870s by French sculptor Fréderic Auguste Bartholdi after the establishment of the French Third Republic to show the fraternal feeling between the republics of the United States and France.  The Second French Republic had collapsed after the Franco-Prussian War. Bartholdi’s hometown in Alsace had passed into German control, which supposedly influenced Bartholdi’s great interest in independence, liberty, and self-determination.

The inspiration for the statue brings us to Italy.  Until now, many people thought that Bartholdi modeled Lady Liberty after a statue that stands on the balcony above the main entrance to the Duomo in Milan.  Sculpted by Camillo Pacetti in 1810, this statue is 75 years older than the one in New York.  Both hold a torch with their right hand, and both wear a crown and a tunic. The only difference is what they hold in their left hand.  The one in Milan holds a cross, and the one in New York holds a book with the Independence Day date on it.

But now comes word that Bartholdi’s statue in New York could be the “younger sister” of a monument in the Basilica of Santa Croce in Florence.  “Freedom of Poetry” was sculpted by Pio Fedi and placed in the church in 1883 as a funeral monument in honor of the Risorgimento patriot, Giovanni Battista Niccolini.  He was a poet and playwright of the Italian unification movement; his 1846 play, Arnold of Bresciawas written in support of unification.

Art in support of history, or in spite of it, brings us back to New York.  The 1880s were difficult times in America.  The threat of social revolution had become palpable.  Striking workers led to violent clashes.  Discrimination on the basis of race, gender, and ethnicity had long run deep, and now prejudice against foreign workers was joining these bigotries.  Despite the abolition of slavery, African-Americans were still profoundly marginalized.  Native Americans were being forced onto reservations.  And now the Statue of Liberty became a flashpoint for suffragists who found it the ultimate expression of hypocrisy:  it represented freedom as a majestic female form in a country in which not one woman was free to vote.

Yet, for many people around the world, the statue represents asylum and freedom for oppressed people. The monument does not feature the usual symbols of American patriotism, such as the flag or the bald eagle.  The tablet in Liberty’s left hand is not the U.S. Constitution; instead it represents the Declaration of Independence, the radical statement of individual and national liberty signed by the American revolutionaries.  Six years after the Statue was installed, Ellis Island opened nearby, through which more than two million immigrants passed on their way to a new life in America.  The immigration center closed in 1954 but on its site now stands the Ellis Island National Museum of Immigration.

It is here that a special exhibition, “Sisters in Liberty” will be held in 2020 jointly sponsored by Florence and the United States.  From a high-resolution 3D scan, a perfect reproduction of the statue in Florence, “Freedom of Poetry” will be displayed.  The exhibition is also connected to the bicentennial of the presence of the American Consulate in Florence:  “It is a profound bond that unites Santa Croce with the United States…and the closeness between the two sister statues is a symbol of this bond, today stronger than ever.”

Posted in Arte, English, Firenze, Foto, Immigrazione, Italia, New York, Storia | 2 Comments

La Trappola

Il teatro: Chiesa di Santa Maria Maddalena a Castelnuovo Magra, un paese di meno di 8.500 abitanti nella provincia di La Spezia, nella regione Liguria.

I protagonisti:

  • Don Alessandro Chiantaretto, parroco di Santa Maria Maddalena
  • Daniele Montebello, sindaco di Castelnuovo Magra
  • “Il Crocifissione” del pittore fiammingo Bruegel il Giovane
  • Il Nucleo Speciale dei Carabinieri che indagano sui furti d’arte
  • Due ladri
  • Un pensionato chiacchierone
  • La stampa internazionale

La data:durante le idi di marzo 2019

Era mezzogiorno in pieno sole.  Il parroco locale stava adempiendo alla sua solita missione quotidiana di portare la comunione ai parrocchiani costretti in casa.  Allo stesso tempo, due uomini sono entrati nella chiesa vuota e si sono diretti verso la cappella laterale.  Lì, in una teca vi era la preziosa “Crocifissione” di Bruegel il Giovane (1564-1638).  Hanno lavorato velocemente.  Hanno fracassato la teca con un martello, hanno rimosso il dipinto del valore di almeno 3 milioni di euro, e sono fuggiti in una Peugeot bianca.  L’auto rombante ha attirato l’attenzione di un residente, che ha visto che la porta della chiesa spalancata, dando così  l’allarme. Il prete, il sindaco e gli abitanti della città erano tutti sconvolti.

Ma cosa è successo veramente?  I carabinieri erano stati avvisati qualche settimana prima che i ladri avevano messo gli occhi sul quadro di Bruegel.  Anche don Alessandro era preoccupato per la crescente attenzione rivolta alla chiesa. “I turisti sono sempre arrivati dal Belgio, dall’Olanda e persino dal Giappone, ma ultimamente ce ne sono stati anche molti italiani.  Quando ho iniziato a trovare bottiglie di birra lasciate davanti al dipinto, ho sospettato che tra i turisti ci fossero anche quelli che erano interessati al dipinto per le ragioni poco onorevoli”.  Don Alessandro ama l’arte e conosce a memoria questo dipinto fiammingo perché da bambino amava disegnare in particolare tre soggetti: Batman, Paperino, e le opere di Bruegel.

Quindi, i Carabinieri, il parroco, e il sindaco hanno organizzato un piano. Hanno rimosso il dipinto originale, lo hanno sostituito con un falso e hanno installato camere di sicurezza. Hanno anche accettato di mantenere questo segreto.  Ma i cittadini non si sono fatti ingannare facilmente. Il Sindaco Daniele Montebello ha detto, “Avevo dei residenti nel mio ufficio, sospettosi perché questo dipinto sembrava diverso. Ho provato a sminuire, dicendo a tutti che era solo un’impressione”. La copia, infatti, era molto più luminosa dell’originale e mancava della tipica ruvidezza delle pennellate.

Quando si è diffuse la notizia del furto, Castelnuovo si è trovata al centro dell’attenzione. Un pensionato chiacchierone non ha potuto resistere alla tentazione di raccontare la storia. Il sindaco è stato inondato di telefonate e richieste di interviste non solo dai media italiani, ma anche dal New York Times, dalla CNN e persino dai giornali canadesi. La vera storia, hanno riferito, è che i ladri hanno rubato un dipinto falso cadendo in una trappola posta dai Carabinieri.

Il dipinto, che erano nel mirino dei ladri, è un olio su cinque pannelli di quercia che mostra la crocifissione dall’alto.  Può essere basato su un lavoro svolto dal padre dell’artista, Bruegel il Vecchio.  È simile a un’altra opera di Bruegel il Giovane, ospitata dal Philadelphia Museum of Art.  Il record raggiunto all’asta dal giovane Bruegel è di $10,7 milioni, ottentuto da Christie nel 2011 per The Battle Between Carnival and Lent.

E adesso? Padre Chiantaretto dice che la chiesa, come al solito, rimane aperta tutto il giorno, in modo che i visitatori possano pregare e apprezzare le sue numerose opere d’arte. Ma lui teme che il furto – anche del falso – lo costringerà a limitare l’accesso. “Quando le chiese sono come i musei, si deve avere uno staff o dei volontari, altrimenti le si deve chiuderle”. L’Italia rimane una destinazione popolare per i ladri per il suo ricco patrimonio culturale e per il notevole numero di chiese – piene di arte – che rimangono aperte e gratuite al pubblico. La buona notizia è che il crimine artistico è diminuito in Italia da 906 reati a 449, rispettivamente dal 2011 al 2016.

E questo è senza dubbio in parte dovuto alla vigilanza del Nucleo Speciale dei Carabinieri, che sta indagando su questo caso sotto la più stretta segretezza. L’unica cosa che i Carabinieri diranno è che questo è stato probabilmente un caso su commissione e che trovare i ladri è “solo una questione di tempo”.

Posted in Arte, Foto, Italia, Italiano, Liguria | Leave a comment

The Trap

The scene: Church of Santa Maria Maddalena in Castelnuovo Magra, a town of less than 8,500 people in the province of La Spezia, region of Liguria.

The protagonists:

  • Don Alessandro Chiantaretto, parish priest of Santa Maria Maddalena;
  • Daniele Montebello, mayor of Castelnuovo Magra;
  • “The Crucifixion” by the Flemish painter Pieter Brueghel the Younger;
  • The Special Unit of the Carabinieri that investigates art theft;
  • Two art thieves;
  • A talkative pensioner; and
  • The international press

The date:  Around the Ides of March 2019

It was the middle of the day in bright sunlight.  The parish priest of Santa Maria Maddalena was on his usual mission to bring communion to housebound parishioners.  Two men entered the empty church and headed directly for the side chapel.  There, in a glass case was the precious “Crucifixion” by the Flemish painter Brueghel the Younger (1564-1638).  They worked quickly.  They smashed the case with a hammer, removed the painting worth at least 3 million euros, and sped off in a white Peugeot.  The screeching car attracted the attention of a resident, who saw that the church door was wide open, and raised the alarm.  The priest, the mayor, and the townspeople were all distraught.

But what really happened? The Carabinieri had been tipped off weeks earlier that burglars had set their sights on the Brueghel painting.  Don Alessandro was also worried about the increasing attention to this church.  “Tourists have always arrived from Belgium, Holland, and even Japan.  Lately, however, also many Italians.  When I started to find beer bottles left in front of the painting, I suspected that among the tourists could also be those who were interested in the painting for less honorable reasons.”  Don Alessandro loves art and knows this Flemish painting by heart because as a child he loved to draw three subjects in particular: Batman, Donald Duck, and the works of Brueghel.

So the Carabinieri, the parish priest, and the town mayor hatched a plan.  They removed the original painting for safe keeping, substituted a fake, and installed security cameras.  And they agreed to keep this secret.  But the townspeople weren’t easily fooled.  Mayor Daniele Montebello said, “I had residents in my office, suspicious because this painting looked different.  I tried to play it down, telling everyone that it was just an impression.”  The copy, in fact, was much brighter than the original and lacked the typical roughness of the brushstrokes.

When news of the theft got out, Castlenuovo found itself the center of attention.  One talkative pensioner could not resist the temptation to tell the story.  The mayor was flooded with phone calls and interview requests not only from the Italian media, but also from the New York Times, CNN, and Canadian newspapers, among others.  The real story is that the thieves stole a fake painting by falling into a trap set by the Carabinieri.

The target painting is an oil on five oak panels that shows the Crucifixion from above.  It may be based on a work done by the artist’s father, Pieter Brueghel the Elder.  It is similar to another of Bruegel the Younger’s work which is housed in the Philadelphia Museum of Art.  The younger Brueghel’s auction record stands at more $10.7 million, set at Christie’s in 2011 for The Battle Between Carnival and Lent.

What now?  Father Chiantaretto says that the church usually remains open all day, so visitors can pray or appreciate its many artworks. But he fears that the theft—even of a fake—would force him to limit access.  “When churches are like museums, you either must have staff or volunteers, or you close them.”  Italy remains a popular destination for thieves because of its rich cultural heritage and the plethora of churches –filled with art — that remain open and free to the public.  The good news is that art crime has fallen in Italy from a reported 906 incidents in 2011 to 449 in 2016.

And this is no doubt in part due to the vigilance of the Special Unit of the Carabinieri, which is investigating this case under the strictest secrecy.  The only thing the Carabinieri will say is that this was probably a case undertaken on commission and that locating the thieves is “only a matter of time.”

Posted in Arte, English, Italia, Liguria | 2 Comments