The Response to the Pandemic:  Italy vs. America

In the following post, I have borrowed generously from an opinion piece in the New York Times from July 2020, and I have added my own thoughts and observations.

Italy was the first Western nation to experience a major wave of the Covid-19 pandemic.  Hospitals became overwhelmed, and the initial death toll was terrible.  But then Italy moved quickly to do what was necessary to deal with the coronavirus.  It instituted a very severe lockdown and kept to it.  You may remember the videos on social media of mayors of Italian towns and cities who walked out into their communities and pleaded, exhorted, and even screamed at citizens to stay home; they were funny, but also deadly serious.  After a few weeks, cases peaked, and then the numbers began a steep decline.

In the United States, cases plateaued for a couple of months.  States started to reopen, and then cases began to rise rapidly.  Death rates followed.  The numbers got frighteningly out of hand, particularly in the south.  Too many Americans arrogantly thought that “If Italy can do it, we can do it better.  We are the largest and strongest nation on earth.”

It is true that Italy has some major disadvantages compared to the United States.  The economy has been stagnant for some time; the country is deeply in debt and without its own currency cannot print money to extricate itself.  The ratio of seniors to working-age adults is among the highest in the Western world.  And in facing a new phenomenon like a pandemic, Italy is not known for its bureaucratic efficiency nor for its citizens’ willingness to follow the rules.  Those may be national stereotypes, but look whose citizens actually defied stay-at-home orders and mask wearing in the name of individualism?  Whose citizens defiantly and selfishly said, “Nobody can tell me what to do”?

Italy has one huge advantage that the United States lacks:  Leadership.  The Prime Minister and the Government took the pandemic seriously: they quickly initiated policies, like the auto certification forms to leave home during the lockdown.  Government aid helped to sustain workers and businesses.  Pandemic supplies were mobilized.  Of course, there were flaws in the response, but even the Prime Minister apologized to the country for delays in aid and took steps to resolve the problem.

Not so in the United States.  The response, if you can call it that, from the President has been abysmal.   First, he denied that there was a pandemic, then he said it would go away.  Then he advocated phony remedies like ingesting bleach.  He didn’t listen to top scientists and epidemiologists.  He still doesn’t.  He insisted on reopening before it was safe. He wouldn’t wear a mask.  He has tied funding to the states based on reopening the schools.  Empathy for those who have suffered—none.

Plan A was to get the economy going again; when that didn’t work, there was no Plan B.   Now Americans can look longingly at Italy’s success in containing the coronavirus.  Restaurants and bars are open there, albeit with restrictions, and much of normal life has returned.  Italy’s numbers are a tiny fraction of those in the United States.  We have become a pathetic figure on the world stage.

But we must not be paralyzed.  The election is less than 100 days away.  We must each do an active part to ensure that Trump is not re-elected.  I am supporting the Lincoln Project, whose goal is defeat Trump and Trumpism.  Ironically, it was started by Republican campaign operatives who share in this one iron-clad goal.  Their ads are brilliant and tough and can be viewed on YouTube.  It is not hyperbole to state that Trump is an authoritarian dictator.  He must be removed from office.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The Response to the Pandemic:  Italy vs. America

  1. Sue Mellor says:

    Thanks for spreading this important message during this critical time. Sue

    On Thu, Jul 30, 2020 at 10:45 AM L’Olivo Santa Barbara wrote:

    > babbityjean posted: “In the following post, I have borrowed generously > from an opinion piece in the New York Times from July 2020, and I have > added my own thoughts and observations. Italy was the first Western nation > to experience a major wave of the Covid-19 pandemic. Ho” >

  2. Frank Vollero says:

    Thank you Barbara, well said!

  3. Marie Panzera says:

    Brava, Cara Barbara.

    Un abbraccio forte

    Sent from my iPad

  4. Penny Bryan says:

    I have joyfully followed you for years. This is one of your best pieces yet.
    I hope every eligible American will exercise their right to vote this November, and we can renew our democracy so in danger of disappearing. This means giving the new President, a majority in the Senate and House as well. In the future we need to build a strong and fair two party system once again, but right now the country needs to change direction.

    Look at what Italy has done. I am as proud of Italy as I am disappointed in this country’s lack of leadership and commitment to its people of all ages and circumstances. No empathy, no compassion, just a fomenting of fear and hate.
    Claims of voter fraud through mail in ballots are FALSE.
    I dream about a future time when Italy will welcome us back.
    I miss Italy.
    Thank you.

  5. Marie Panzera says:

    Brave and intelligent words. He — and his sycophants — must go.

    Sent from my iPad

  6. Barbara Smith says:

    Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.